Section 1 builds an initial case for the thesis that nonconsequentialist utilitarianism is not a contradiction in terms. Ethics 1 criticisms of consequentialism and kantian ethics may, 2002 key concepts first hour moral rules and moral rights justice as one part of morality morally relevant difference between acts and omissions intuition and reflective equilibrium. By remaining closer to kants own view of the aims of ethics, woods understanding of kantian ethics differs from the received constructivist interpretation, especially on such matters as the ground and function of ethical principles, the nature of ethical reasoning and autonomy as the ground of ethics. I believe i will eat sand because it is the standard meal for my community. In this way, the rule consequentialist can ensure that there will be rules pertaining to non. The purpose of this article is to explain different ethical theories and compare and contrast them in a way thats clear and easy for students to understand. Deontology the word comes from the greek deon meaning one must denies this, and asserts that there are several distinct duties, not all of which depend for their status as duties on considerations of value alone. Dignity, contractualism and consequentialism 385 have not been impressive. Pettit says honouring constraints leads to nonconsequentialism. I am learning about these three theories now and i feel a lot of sympathy towards consequentialism, specifically rule utilitarianism.
Act utilitarianism au is the moral theory that holds that the morally right action, the act. In its simplest form, consequentialism claims that we only have one moral duty. But this new form of consequentialism, which follows from kants theory, has a distinctly kantian tone. Which theory influences your everyday life the most. Cummiskeys kantian consequentialism volume 12 issue 1 richard dean. There are three major categories of ethical systems that students typically learn about in philosophy classes. Virtue ethics, kantian ethics and consequentialism introduction contemporary theories of virtue ethics are often presented as theories that are in opposition to kantian ethics and consequentialist ethics. While kant himself was not a consequentialist, cummiskey thinks he should have been, given his fundamental positions in ethics. Kantian consequentialism argues that kants basic rationalist, internalist approach to the justification of normative principles, his conception of morality as a system of categorical imperatives, his account of the nature of the goodwill and the motive of duty, and his principle of universalizability are all compatible with normative consequentialism.
The two tiers of value in kantian consequentialism are meant to address these issues see cummiskey, kantian, ch. The choice between consequentialist and kantian ethics is a dif. Despite this, such forms of these views seem to have become almost. Kantian deontology revision notes teaching resources. In kantian consequentialism, david cummiskey argues that the central ideas of kants moral philosophy provide claims about value which, if applied consistently, lead to consequentialist normative principles. Consequentialism stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Differences between consequentialism and kantianism. If the linked material requires signing up to view, even if the account is free, it is not allowed. Capital punishment is based on kantian retributive justice. While kant himself was not a consequentialist, cummiskey thinks he. Immanuel kant 17241804 is generally considered to be one of the most profound and original philosophers who ever lived. First, since consequentialist principles may require unacceptable sacrifices of some for the benefit of others.
Cummiskey kantian consequentialism 587 sacrifice others, or ourselves, because to do so would be to treat persons as a means only. On distributionsensitive consequentialism, also see scheffler, samuel, the rejection of consequentialism oxford, 1982. Subjective telling right from wrong paternalism vs. As candidates for the fundamental moral principle, rule consequentialism, and kantian contractualism may find their prima facie most charming and intuitively plausible forms when they are formulated by appealing to certain properties of everyones accepting a set of rules. In consequentalist ethics, the morality or immorality of an action is determined by the outcome of that action. Consequentialism, as its name suggests, is simply the view that normative properties depend only on consequences. Kants ethics so far in our discussion of ethics we have been focusing on different versions of consequentialism the view that one is morally obliged to pursue the course of action which, of the available alternatives, will produce the best outcome. German philosopher immanuel kant 17241804 was an opponent of consequentialism, and propagated a deontological moral theory of ethics, which is popularly known as kantianism theory of ethics. Google drive links and link shorteners are not allowed. For one thing, the criterion dispute includes a dispute about whether there is any such moral instinct.
Metaposts, products, services, surveys, amas and links to other areas of reddit require moderator preapproval. Kant and consequentialism reflections on cummiskeys kantian. He was perhaps most known for his work critique of practical reason which looked at the. Consequentialism and deontology bibliography philpapers. In ethics, kant seeks a rational derivation of our moral duty. To understand his view of the good will, we therefore need to understand what duty is. Utilitarianism, kantian ethics, natural rights theories, and religious ethics a utilitarian argument, in the strict sense, is one what alleges that we ought to do something because it will produce more total happiness than doing anything else would. Therefore one can conclude that consequentialism is that the validation of actions is to be found in consequences. One reason that is commonly put forward to justify this opposition is that they take different moral.
The author based on the ethics of social consequences as a form of nonutilitarian consequentialism claims like cummiskey, that there are similarities between kant s ethics and consequentialism. Thus, from a consequentialist standpoint, a morally right act or omission from acting is one that will produce a good outcome, or consequence. Brief revision notes for kantian deontology, suitable for as a2 philosophy or religious studies students. This historically important and still popular theory embodies the basic intuition that what is best or right is whatever makes the world best in the future, because we cannot change the past, so worrying about the past is no more useful than crying over spilled milk.
I unlike consequentialism, it is highly unsituational. Utilitarianism, kantian ethics, natural rights theories. Posts must not be behind any sort of paywall or registration wall. Thomas scanlon and frances kamm, however, have offered two interesting and in. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Kantian normative theories abound, but most share a rejection of consequentialist normative principles and an emphasis on the importance of autonomy. Nonconsequentialism and universalizability by philip pettit if nonconsequentialists are to embrace the requirement of universalizability, then they will have to adopt a surprisingly relativistic stance. Immanuel kant 17241804 born in konigsberg, prussia, now kaliningrad, russia. Virtue ethics, kantian ethics and consequentialism. Through scrupulous analysis of kants writings and exhaustive consideration of recent scholarship on kant, cummiskey demonstrates that the foundations of kantian thought are the basis for an enriched understanding of moral principles and values. Since consequentialism may sometimes require us to aggress against some persons in order to aid others, it does not respect. According to the kantian, what are really good or bad are not the consequences of our actions, but the actions themselves. Deontological ethics routledge encyclopedia of philosophy. According to kant, a good will is a will that chooses a certain action because it is the action dictated by duty.
Louis introduces us to the ethical theory of consequentialism. What you should know about kants ethics in a nutshell. In this wireless philosophy video, julia driver washington university in st. Deontology and consequentialism, again notes on liberty. Home philosophy home philosophy home philosophy a concise introduction to ethics home philosophy a concise introduction to ethics a concise introduction to ethics instructor resources shaferlandau, a concise introduction to ethics 1e student resources. Ethics is concerned with moral philosophy and revolves around such issues as right or wrong, good or bad, virtue or vice, and justice or injustice.
He is equally well known for his metaphysicsthe subject of his critique of pure reasonand for the moral philosophy set out in his groundwork to the metaphysics of morals and critique of practical reason although. Kant calls rules which say what we ought to do imperatives. Pdf in his article, the author considers possible forms of relationship between kants ethics and consequentialism. Criticisms of consequentialism and kantian ethics may. Recent years have witnessed a renewed debate over the costs at which the benefits of free markets have. I believe people should be able to eat sand if they want to because they are free to make the decision themselves.
Rule consequentialism and kantian contractualism at top. We will see, however, that their arguments tacitly appeal to a nonkantian conception of the special value and. Kant s treatment of utilitarianism and consequentialism further complicates the task of combining deontological and consequentialist concepts into modern liberal projects. Autonomy paternalism authority of restricting the freedom and responsibilities of those lower than them autonomy is a binomial 1 enlightenment ethics. In cases where it looks like honouring gives the best result it is actually promoting it too. Deontological ethics i deontological ethics says that being good consists in following the right rulesmeeting all your obligations. Basic proposition of kantianism is that action of people should not depend upon consequences, rather should be dictated by categorical imperatives that fulfil duty of human being.
Immanuel kant was born in 1724 and was a renowned german philosopher with huge influences on modern philosophy. Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of ones conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of that conduct. Criticisms of consequentialism and kantian ethics may phil 240. Since my first real introduction to libertarianism was harvard theorist robert nozick, i originally envisioned the philosophy as a rightsbased, and thereby in some sense deontological, political theory, with likeminded. Christopher freiman, associate professor in philosophy at william and mary and writer at bleeding heart libertarians, identifies as both a libertarian and utilitarian.
221 257 830 225 849 1274 1616 1049 929 1312 1604 936 1272 94 1418 448 387 1562 751 738 825 846 885 1275 1443 1475 329 957 1005 1494 1185 1320 347 1106 11 1038 1035 388